No One in a Powdered Wig is Scrappy

It’s taking the culture by storm, the biggest Broadway musical in years—and it’s about… the first U.S. secretary of the treasury, Alexander Hamilton? It seems unlikely, but nothing about the “Hamilton” story is likely. Lin-Manuel Miranda took the biography of a lesser-known early American figure and turned it into a story full of catchy songs and social commentary, including the rapid-fire hip-hop lyrics and the casting of non-white actors in most of the parts. Four of our “Hamilton”-mad panelists discuss the appeal of the show and why it works so incredibly well.

(This we’ve also launched an entire podcast devoted to “Hamilton”, so if you want to hear various panels discuss the show song by song, you may want to subscribe to that, too.)

Piano intro and outro music from Hamilton played by Christopher Breen.

Jason Snell with Serenity Caldwell, Monty Ashley, David J. Loehr and Chip Sudderth

Download file (37 M)


  • Casper: High-quality, comfortable mattresses at a remarkable price and with a 100-day return policy. Use code SNELL for $50 off.

  • Enclosed: A subscription service of delicate items for the woman in your life. Use code SNELL for $25 off any multi-month order.

  • TeeVee: A podcast from your pals at The Incomparable about various TV shows, currently including “The Expanse,” “The Flash,” “Arrow,” and “Legends of Tomorrow.”

Want to comment on this episode?

Or become a member and join our special members-only community!